Mill Creek Cemetery is located at the corner of Dodge Drive and Old Glenrose in Nashville. The cemetery grew around Mill Creek Baptist Church, which was organized in 1795 by the Menees and Whitsitt families. The first church services were held in the Menees's home and also in member's homes. In 1797 a log house was erected for services. Membership grew and in 1810 a larger, brick meeting house was built at the present site of Mill Creek Cemetery.
MILL CREEK BAPTIST CHURCH GRAVEYARD
Mr. James Whitsitt, son-in-law of Mr. James Menees, was one of the first pastors at Mill Creek Baptist Church. A number of Baptist Churches grew from Mill Creek's mission work. These include Antioch, First Church, Nashville, Grandview, Concord, Rock Springs, and Providence. The State Baptist Convention was organized at Mill Creek in 1833 and the church prospered until the early 1900's. As the area grew the need for a more accessible church may have contributed to the closing of Mill Creek. The building was dismantled in the mid 1900's.
Old-timers tell of horse and wagon processions to services at Mill Creek Cemetery. Some say cattle grazed the property in later years. Some tell of swimming in nearby Mill Creek amid tombstones which were scattered on the banks and in the creek.
Today, nothing remains of the old church. The site contains approximately 150 known and several unknown graves of early settlers, pioneers, and slaves. Unfortunately, many of the markers have fallen and have been vandalized.
This list has been compiled from several sources. These include Davidson County, TN Death Records & Tombstone Inscriptions by Richard C. Fulcher, 1979 and Mill Creek Baptist Church Graveyard by Albert and Edythe R. Whitley, 1929. Other researchers who have recorded lists of the cemetery include Jeff and Linda Therber, from a site inspection in 1988 and Janie Ridley Bice, from site inspections in 1992-1996. Due to the span in years of these documents and subsequent vandalizing of stones, discrepancies do exist. Genealogical research on the Ridley-Everett-Buchanan families substantiates many of the names and dates of these families but does not always coincide with earlier research. The oldest burial date appears to be 1813 and the earliest documented birth date appears to be 1737. According to Whitley's research in 1929 there were, at that time, some hundred graves with no markings. Among these are some rock slabs which are standing but have no means of identification. This is one of the largest of the old cemeteries in Middle Tennessee as stated by the Whitleys, so it is possible as many as 240 gravesites exist.
List of known persons buried at Mill Creek Cemetery:Where information is not given or it is unclear a (?) is used. An asterisk (*) is used for wooden or stone markers. Birth dates and death dates are given in that order. Several members of the Whitsett family are in one plot surrounded by a rock wall and a rock wall surrounds many members of the Ridley, Everett, and Buchanan families. Other graves are situated throughout the cemetery area. This list will identify graves in alphabetical order.
Name Dates Remarks Drucilla A. Allen 1810-1838 - Andrew Baker, Sr. 1762-1845 - Mary Banniza (?) - 1864 - Nancy Banniza 1856-1856 - Willie Banniza (?) - 1874 - Enoch M. Beaty 1858 - 1871 - Charles Birthright (?) - (?) - InfantEliza Ann Birthright 1825-1850 - Nancy J. Birthright 1828-1888 - Charles B(Bingley) Buchanan 28 Oct 1809-16 Apr 1856 (son of Maj John & Sally Ridley) James R.(Ridley) Buchanan 1831-1833 (son of Moses Ridley Buchanan & Sarah Ridley) Moses Ridley Buchanan 4 Apr1806-30 May1887 (son of John & Sally Ridley Buchanan) F.F.B. (?) - (?) - John Wolf Capps 1873-1896 - John Carter 1839- 1842 - Ann B. Cartwright 1812- 1851 - Mary Cartwright 1800- 1842 - William G. Cartwright 1822- 1915 - Caroll Corbitt 1827- 1858 - Eldridge A. Corbitt 182?- 18? - James Corbitt 1808- 1872 - Lucy Corbitt 1800- 1856 - Sarah A. G. Corbitt 1837- 1838 - (?) Corbitt 1849-1850 - J.L.C.C. 1882-(?)* - L.C.L.C.C. 1842-(?)* - Christiana Demonbreum 1787-9 Apr 1850 - (wife of Timothy Demonbreum, dau. of Capt. John Rains) Haynes M. Demonbreum 13 Nov 1831- (?) - Henry Demonbreum (?) - (?) - James Demonbreum 13 Nov 1831 - (?) - S.B. Demonbreum 14 Mar1856-3 Jul 1856 (son of M.R. & Elizabeth) Douglas S. Dobie 1890- 1893 - James P. Downs 1776- 1819 - Martha DuBose (?)- (?) - Elizabeth Everett 29 Dec 1795-8 May 1875 (wife of Thomas, dau.Maj.John Buchanan) - Emma Everett 15 Mar1854-1Oct1854 (grandaughter Thomas Everett/Elizabeth Buchanan) Frank Everett Apar- 4 Jun1858 (grandson Thomas H.Everett/Elizabeth Buchanan) John Buchanan Everett 1850-1852 (grandson of Thomas H. Everett/Elizabeth Buchanan) Thomas Hardeman Everett Jun 1783-29 Mar 1854 (son of John Everett/Lydia Hardeman) William Blandon Everett (?) - (?) - Infant Daughter Everett 1857- 1857 (granddaughter Thomas Everett/Elizabeth Buchanan) Fannie (?) 1776-1838* - Mrs. J. L. (Bettie) Ferguson (?) - 1921 - Enoch Fly 1799-1866 - M.M. Fly 1807- 1844 - Lena Foster (?)-1 Jun 1881 age 3 of cholera, child of Thomas Foster Robert A. Foster 6 Apr 1900 stillborn, grandchild of Thomas Foster Thomas Foster (?)-12 May 1881 age 52, occupation - cooper, Nashville death record #380 Betsy Goodrich (?)-(?) - Billy Goodrich (?)-(?) - Hays J. Goodrich 1816-1886 - Mary Tennessee Goodrich 1848-1850 - Minerva Goodrich 1827-1905 - Polly Goodrich (?)- (?) - Robert L. Goodrich 1864-1900 - George Godwin 1796-1835 - Jane T. Godwin 1802-1837 - Douglas Larkin Gunter 1907-1907 - Samuel Ham 1775-1854 - Joseph Daniel Harvey 1854-1918 - Albert W. Higley (?) - 1939 - Annis W. Higley 1888-1945 - A.J. Hill 1819-1851 - Alie (?) Hill 1876 - 1881 - J.P. Hill 1817-1849 - (Infant) Hill 1849-1849 - John Holmes (?)-1876 - James A. Hutchison 1865-1940 - Eliza Jarrel 1812-(?) - Elizabeth Jarrel 1835-1841 - Minerva Jarrel 1837-1845 - E.G. Johnson 1890- 1893 - Penelope H. Johnson 1828- 1845 - Mary Leath 1812- 1851 - Broadus Lovell 1797- 1881 - Elizabeth M. Lovell 1894- 1931 - Florence J. Lovell 1864-1922 - George A. Lovell 182(?)-1882 - George W. Lovell 1809-1882 - Ida Lovell (?) - 1884 - Margaret Lovell 1799-1879(?) - Paul Lovell 1885-1903 - Jacob B. Martin (?) - 1822 - William Hamilton Miller 1908-1909 - Cora E. Murray 1856-1857 - Nannie Susan Newman 1862-1862 - Susan A. Newman 18(?) -1862 - William Osmar (?) - 1841 - Mrs. Nancy M. Perry 1817-1875 - Ann Ridley 15 Jan 1786- 2 Feb 1857 - G. Ridley (?) - 2 June 1901 - George Ridley 11 Jan 1737 - 29 Nov 1835 - George T. Ridley 31 Jan 1858-30 Jan 1885 (son of Moses McNairy & Mary E.) James Ridley, Sr. 24 May 1784 - 30 Aug 1847 (son of George and Sarah Vincent Ridley) James Ridley, Jr. 8 Feb 1814 - 31 Jan 1886 (son of James Sr. and Ann Hamilton Ridley) John E.B.(Elliott Baker) Ridley 6 Oct 1842 - 13 Jan 1862 (son of Moses M. & Mary E.) Mary Ann Ridley 1807- 1 Sep 1817 (dau. of James Sr. & Ann Ridley) Mary E.(Elizabeth Baker) Ridley 15 Nov 1822 - 19 Jan 1862 (wife of Moses M. Ridley) Mary E. (Elizabeth)Ridley 15 Sep 1854 - 8 Aug 1855 (dau.of Mary & Moses Ridley) Sally (Sarah Elizabeth Vincent) Ridley 16 Jul 1810-28 Jan 1864 (dau.James & Ann) Samuel J. (Jones) Ridley 1 Oct 1791 - 6 Dec 1827 (son of George & Sarah Ridley) Samuel Jones Ridley 3 Dec 1807 - 15 Sep 1824 (1st born son James & Ann Ridley) Samuel Jones Ridley Jr. Dec 1827 - 17 May 1843 (last born son James & Ann Ridley) Sarah Ridley 1 May 1754 - 20 Mar 1836 (wife of George Ridley Sr) Sarah B.(Buchanan Everett) Ridley 7 Aug 1811 - 17 Sep 1837 (wife of Hance H.Ridley) Vincent B. Ridley 5 Dec 1860 - 8 Jun 1863 (son of Moses M. & Mary E. Ridley) Infant son Ridley Dec 1822 - 12 Aug 1822 (son of James & Ann Ridley) Infant daughter Ridley ?-4 Jun 1824 (dau. of James & Ann Ridley) - Infant son Ridley 1855-1855 - Elizabeth Sanders 1769-1849 - Elvira Scot (?) - 1896 - Jean Reid Shannon (?) - (?) - Joe Smallman (Infant) ? - David L. Tanksley 1858-1858 - Frank C. Tanksley 1866-1868 - George W. Tanksley 1849-1852 - James A. Tanksley 1824-1886 - James B. Tanksley 1851-1851 - James D. Tanksley 1860-1886 - Lemuel Lewis Tanksley 1855-1864 - Martha E. Tanksley 1828- 1878 - Mary Ann Elizabeth Tanklsey 1842- 1842 - Mary Emma Tanksley 1848-1851 - Nancy Tanksley 1807(?) - (?) - Nancy Adaline Tanksley 1845-1845 - William Tanksley 1817-1830 - William A. Tanksley 1854-1855 - Comfort (Everett)Topp 1773-1860 - John Topp 1769-1835 - Mary B. Turberville 1796 - 1885 - W.C. Turberville 1795 - 1848 - Joseph Vick (?) - 1844 - James S. Walker 1811- 1891 - Willie Warner 1861- 1861 - James H. Webb 1856 - 1929 - Mildred W. Webb 1866 - 1951 - Sam Porter Whitsett 1836 - 1925 - Seluda Harvey Whitsett 1844 - 1917 - (Infant) Whitsett 1849-1849 - Jean P. Whitsett 1874 - 1949 - Robert Allen Whitsett 1888 - 1934 - Will P. Willis 1827 - 1852 - Infant Wood (?)-Sept 1894 3 day old female child, daughter of Gus Woods, Nashville death record #1131 _______________________
Cemeteries of Nashville and Davidson County